The Pie Hole

Anonymous Dec 9, 2017 at 8:48AM

I stopped by this place because it looked so cute inside but it ended up being a bad experience for me. I ordered pumpkin pie and I asked if they served ice cream with it. I then asked if they could warm up my pie and put the ice cream on top and the cashier said yes. Unfortunately adding whip cream and ice cream cost a lot of $$. In total we paid about $18 for two slices of pie (only one with whip and ice cream). When they brought my piece of pie, it was cold. So I asked if they could warm it up and she said no because it is custard and it would fall apart. I then asked if they could do it for 30 seconds because I don't ever eat pumpkin pie cold and they said no. I asked for a refund on the ice cream and whip cream but only got the ice cream refunded. The cashier denied that I asked her if it could be warmed up but I think it was clear that I did. Anyways the whole the was a big turn off and I won't be coming back because it made me uncomfortable and it's way too expensive. Good luck out there.

Anonymous Dec 8, 2017 at 10:38AM

Damn, this is some great pie. Menu is always changing and they keep it fresh. It's a bit on the expensive side for pie ($6-8 per slice) but it's so worth it. I recommend buying a slice of a sweet pie and one of their savory hand pie for the balance. If you get a chance, try the chicken and waffle hand pie, so good. Most sweet pies are good too, but unless you have a real sweet tooth and don't mind the crash later, stay away from the Mexican Chocolate pie. Or if you get it, split it with someone. It tastes great, but it's like Mexican candy: sugar, wrapped in sugar, baked in sugar, and topped with chocolate (that has little sugar granules).

Anonymous Dec 6, 2017 at 8:33AM

Shepherds pie is it, also loved the chicken one too. Thought I could eat about for of them and couldn't finish two. They are so delicious and filling that you will hurt yourself eating there.

Anonymous Nov 22, 2017 at 10:56PM

Awesome spot in the arts district to sit around and gain weight...but seriously I crave their pies all the time now. There are savory and sweet options, and they also have a full coffee menu.

Anonymous Oct 31, 2017 at 11:34AM

Omg. Such good pie. Seriously. Blue Stove in Brooklyn watch out! Earl Grey pie? Yes and its delicious! Great coffee too

Anonymous Sep 3, 2017 at 10:09PM

If you can score a custard pie on a day that it it is available, you will score a piece of heaven. That pie is absolutely amazing. The earl grey is decent, but the custard by far shines the most here.

Anonymous Aug 28, 2017 at 11:18PM

This pie shop is AMAZING. The Shepherd's pie is easily my favorite. If you are looking for something sweeter, the Earl Grey Tea pie is unique and SO ADDICTIVE. You'll be back for more

Anonymous Jul 25, 2017 at 8:28PM

Everything is pie! Small, busy and they put corn in the "chicken and waffle" pie. It's great for a group but parking is not ideal. It can be romantic, if you like rustic barn style restaurants, they serve everything in a pie tin. I feel the food is overrated, but customer service is pretty decent.

Anonymous Jul 11, 2017 at 10:56PM

Hands down the best, freshest, and tastiest pie I've ever had. Staff is friendly and helpful and the prices are very reasonable for the gourmet level pies they serve. They have a diverse menu, ranging from standard fare such as apple pie and blueberry pancakes pie to some more exocitc flavors like strawberry rosemary hand pies.

Anonymous Jun 19, 2017 at 5:26AM

Fabulous selection of delicious pies, both sweet and savoury. Also, great coffee, far, far better than you get at Starbucks or similar crappy places. Decor is quite hip and cool. Great ambience, fantastic food, excellent coffee. Recommended!

Anonymous Jan 27, 2017 at 5:17AM

Pies, Pies everywhere! The Pies they have here are pretty decent I've been here a handful of times and my favorite is still just the regular pumpkin pie they have during the pumpkin spice season. I've heard good things about the earl grey pie, but havent had the chance to try it yet. Check this place out if you're into Pies

Anonymous Jan 6, 2017 at 12:14PM

The Earl Grey pie was delicious and not overly sweet like others mentioned. The hot cocoa also has a good dark chocolate flavor to it. We appreciated the friendly staff...We were just visiting and they gave us good recommendations for their menu as well as other places to visit. It is a bit expensive and parking is difficult, however we enjoyed it!

Anonymous Jan 5, 2017 at 10:43PM

Good pie and tasty hot drinks. They have teas and coffee that are pretty good. Worth stopping by if you are in the area. the Earl Grey pie is amazing.

Anonymous Nov 9, 2016 at 1:02AM

Great savory pies! My favorite is the chicken and cornbread 🙌🏽 They have sweet pies too. I can eat quite a bit do I usually get two c&c pies. Pricing just went up over the Summer by a $1 so two pies will cost around $14 (as of Nov '16) and they are about 5" in diameter.