Fox Island Creamery

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

We had shrimp & lobster roll with lemon mayo. Large shrimp and chunks of lobster, fries seasoned with old bay and coleslaw with horseradish. We were also given a complementary lobster bisque.

You definitely need to visit! ���������

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Unique and flavorful menu options and wonderful atmosphere and service. My daughter enjoyed the clams and The fish and chips were tasty. We will be coming back.

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

This seafood cafe is awesome! Cold seafood salad followed by lobster bisque and clams and mussels in a in a white sauce. Great Food and compliments to the Chef!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

The most amazing thing I've ever eaten! The staff are so lovely and helpful. I stumbled across the place and am throughly hooked now! ❤️❤️❤️

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Really great ice cream, friendly staff and an outside view to boot! What more can one ask for.

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Ordered takeout for the first time this weekend. Food was fabulous. We got the fillet of flounder sandwich and the jumbo shrimp and lobster roll. So good! We'll be back soon to try other menu items.

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

My husband and I went with another couple and we had a kindergartener and two 2nd graders between us. The kids were happily entertained while we enjoyed delicious food and uninterrupted conversation (parents - remember that?!). Highly recommend the Mediterranean seafood salad and the ahi tuna. Other meals all looked great too. We like that it’s BYOB. There were a few kinks in the ordering/young waitstaff but it’s a new place and I could see some coaching was happening so didn’t drop to 4 Star bc if that. Also - they have non seafood options (eg chicken strips for kids) so try it out! We will be back often!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

I used to always go to DQ... and don't get me wrong. I will always have a soft spot for DQ... but one day my friend said we should try out this new place that is right around the corner from DQ in West Milford. I was like okay... another ice cream place, sure I'll try it out. I was hooked from the first time I set foot in the place! The hard ice cream flavors are absolutely delicious and very homey. So much better than DQ. The prices aren't bad either and what I like the most (besides the delicious ice cream and great atmosphere!), is the fact that I can show up with messy hair and PJs on and the employees won't even bat an eye. They are all so friendly! So here I am, 23 years old, enjoying ice cream, and writing a review. Oh.. and this place is also very clean. I think that is also just as equally important as the rest. I fully recommend this place.

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Great place with gluten free and lactose free choices. Even gluten free cones!!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Great place with a fun nautical atmosphere. If you have young kids they will get a kick of the little play area for them. Chef Michael is an amazing talented chef!. We had the Crab Cake and Lobster Mac and Cheese and everything was delicious. Would definitely go back.

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Great place to spend quality time with your family, while you enjoyed the view of the Upper Greenwood Lake.

You can either get ice cream or frozen yogurt because either choice will be making you very happy 😊 A++

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Great fun! The food is excellent and so is the chef! Very warm and friendly place! Nice add to our town!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Got take out for the boat, 9 orders ,ready in half hour, all meals were delicious! The steamers were to die for!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Fresh food, awesome location and good service. Loved our 3 meals that we ordered and the lobster bisque was very tasty. You gotta try it out. The Raman and salmon dish my daughter had was unique and full of flavor and huge

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Excellent food. Nice staff and nice decor. Delightful place for lunch or dinner.

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Awesome!!!! The ice cream was great, the views were great, and the staff was super friendly! Nice to have a hometown ice cream shop like this!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

5 stars is just not enough for the new cafe! What a wonderful surprise! We walked in not knowing what to order. Super 'under the sea' decor! Chef Scott - or can I say 'crazy' Chef Scott (in a good way �) was SO kind and very passionate asking us what types of seafood we enjoy. The lobster bisque was THE best I have ever had. My husband devoured the muscles entree and I was in heaven with my shrimp/lobster roll. The staff was so friendly. We found a new favorite and can't wait to go back! Highly recommended!!

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

The food was great and the restaurant looks fantastic, pricing is ok and the kitchen staff (mike and maria) were very nice, the only downside was the inexperienced servers, they were very nice but need to be trained a little more. We will definitely be back

Anonymous Oct 18, 2023 at 7:10PM

Ordered take out. Pineapple salad was packaged in its own bag And was awesome.

Mango salad may have been awesome but it was packed in a second bag between two hot dishes and had me wondering if it was supposed to be a warm salad. Also ordered the fish and chips and that was delish, there was no tarter sauce which I was a bit upset about. The corned beef sandwich was not that great, the meat was thick and dry. Regarless, I did order another time but just a pineapple salad and it was good. they said they were adding to the menu and I saw they now have a child’s menu. So besides the corned beef sandwich, I will go back again because all in all I think the young inexperienced servers may have made the errors.